Comment rules and privacy

A thoughtful conversation

Questions and disagreement are welcome. Stay relevant and respectful. Do not post threats, harassment, spam, private case documents or personal information about other people.

What is published

Your chosen display name, comment, posting date and reply relationship may be shown after approval. Use a display name you are comfortable publishing. Comments are displayed as plain text.

Email confirmation and moderation

Every comment requires confirmation through a link sent to your email address, followed by owner review. Confirmation verifies access to an inbox, not a person’s identity or affiliation. Links expire after 24 hours. Your email address is visible only to the site owner and is not published.

The owner may approve, hide, reject or remove comments. Reports go to the owner for review; they do not automatically remove a comment. Comments do not subscribe you to updates or reply notifications.

Storage and delivery

Comments, email addresses, confirmation status and moderation records are stored in the site’s database. Resend processes the email address and confirmation message for delivery.

Abuse prevention uses temporary rate-limit counters keyed by hashes of the submitting IP address or email address. Reports contain the reported comment reference, your reason and the submission time. Do not include sensitive information in reports.

Comments are retained until the owner removes them. Removal clears the comment text, display name and email from the comment record; an internal moderation record remains. Unconfirmed comments can also be removed by the owner. A public contact route for correction or removal requests must be available before comments open.

Back to the journal